
🏕️ Opening Bite
Everyone's waiting for Black Friday to find out how expensive it gets.
Meanwhile, the real problem is it already got expensive.
Same audiences. Same offer. Same ROAS target as last year.
Birch's tracking put US Facebook CPMs at $21.45 in October, higher than Black Friday week 2025.
🪵 We got this wrong: Nothing reported from this week's issues. Last call before BFCM: if anything we told you this month is off, reply and it leads Monday.
Stories Told Around The Camp

🚨 The Big Marketing Story: The Off-Season Is Priced Like Peak
Birch's data on US-targeted Facebook campaigns shows an average CPM of $21.45 in October 2026, against $15.93 in October 2025. That's up 34.6%. 1
For comparison, Black Friday week 2025 averaged $18.40. October this year cost more than last year's peak. 1
The climb wasn't one bad month. July came in at $19.01, August at $20.31, September at $22.30. 1
Other trackers agree on the direction, not the size: Triple Whale +13% through July, Skai +20% for Q3, Northbeam +25% as of October 21, AdKit +40.5% for October's worldwide median. Meta's own Q3 earnings put US and Canada price per ad up 23%. 1
The kicker? At the same click-through and conversion rates, a 34.6% CPM increase turns last year's 2.0 ROAS into about 1.49. Most BFCM plans are still built on last year's target.
Is yours worse than everyone else's? Nobody publishes what operators actually pay, so we're going to. Add your CPM and cost per result to the Campy Index. It takes two minutes, nothing goes out with your name on it, and everyone who adds numbers gets the full breakdown by vertical first.
Survival Skills

🧠 Why This Matters
Last year's target is the wrong number. If CPMs are up a third and your click and conversion rates aren't, your CPA is up a third too. Reset the BFCM target from your margin, not from last November's dashboard.
Rules beat watching. Birch's BFCM playbook: pause an ad when today's spend hits 2 to 3 times your average CPA, and pause an ad set once it has spent 50% of its daily budget with ROAS under target. Add a 7-day ROAS condition so the early-morning zero doesn't kill a winner. 2
Morning numbers are a floor. Meta can credit a purchase to a click up to 28 days earlier or a view in the previous day, and website purchases don't come back with hourly breakdowns. Read peak days by the day, not by the hour. 2
Translation: decide your kill numbers this weekend, not at 9 AM on Black Friday.
📸 See It In Action
Average CPM, US-targeted Facebook campaigns:
Month | 2025 | 2026 |
|---|---|---|
July | $15.49 | $19.01 |
August | $16.02 | $20.31 |
September | $16.02 | $22.30 |
October | $15.93 | $21.45 |
Black Friday week | $18.40 | Next week |
Source: Birch data, compiled by AdMakeAI, Nov 2, 2026
🔍 What Operators Are Doing
Smart operators aren't hoping CPMs come down. They're writing their pause rules now, running them in notify-only mode for a day, and launching Black Friday creative at 6 PM local time on Thanksgiving. 2
🧪 Try This This Week (10 minutes)
Step 1 (4 min): Pull your 30-day average CPA. Create a rule that pauses any ad when today's spend reaches 2.5 times that number. Set it to notify only.
Step 2 (4 min): Create a second rule: pause an ad set when it has spent 50% of its daily budget, today's ROAS is under target, and 7-day ROAS is under target. Notify only.
Step 3 (2 min): Limit both rules to November 26 through 30. Read the logs Monday, then switch them live.
Expected outcome: by Thanksgiving night, your worst ads stop themselves within hours instead of burning a full peak day.
🔦 Around The Fire: show us the plan before you know if it works
Most case studies get written after the result is in. This one runs the other way. Send your BFCM plan now (budget, target CPA or ROAS, the rule you're trusting) and we'll follow up after Cyber Monday with what actually happened.
Win or miss, the first plan in gets the seat. You choose whether we use your name.
⚡ 3 Quick Signals

1. Google: Merchant Center admin changes now need a passkey. Since October 29, adding users and changing permissions requires passkey authentication. If a freelancer or new hire needs access during BFCM week, set your passkey up today. 3
2. Meta: "Acquire new customers" may skip two years of buyers. Jon Loomer reported that the customer lifecycle setting, open to all advertisers since October 6, excludes customers from your conversion data over the past 730 days, with no off switch. That's one practitioner's report, so check your own ad set before counting on it in a returning-buyer BFCM push. 1
3. WhatsApp: the free click-to-WhatsApp window is now up to 7 days. Up from 72 hours since September 29. Business Agent messages inside it are still charged. A Black Friday chat can now be followed up through Cyber Monday without paying per reply. 1
🤖 Tool Watch
Automated rules, used properly. Meta's own automated rules in Ads Manager are free and handle everything in this week's Try This for a single account. If you run BFCM for several clients, Birch's rules can cover up to five ad accounts in the same currency from one rule. Either way, the move that saves you is the same: run every rule in notify-only for a day, then read the log before it touches spend. 2
And for the target itself. Our break-even ROAS calculator takes your margin and gives you the ROAS you need before you keep a dollar. Use that number in the rules above instead of last November's. It's free, and there's no signup.
🔥 Campfire Close
If your Black Friday CPA lands 30% over plan...
it's probably not the creative.
It's that you built the plan on last year's CPMs.
See you around the campfire.
🤝 The Campfire Promise
Six things you can hold us to. Same six, every issue.
No platform money. Meta, Google, TikTok and the ad-tool companies can't buy a slot, an affiliate link or a "partner" post here. When anyone else sponsors an issue, it's labeled, and Jake has used what they sell.
No courses. We will never sell you a $997 anything. The playbooks are free and they stay free.
Every issue ends in a 10-minute action. If you can't do something with it before lunch, we didn't finish writing it.
A reader in every issue. Real accounts, real numbers, credited. Operators publishing operators.
Corrections go at the top. When we miss, you read it above the first story, not in a footnote.
Jake answers every reply. Hit reply. A person who runs ads reads it and writes back.
Caught us breaking one? Reply with the number. That goes at the top of the next issue too.
🍫 Know someone who runs ads?
Forward this to them, or send them your link. One signup gets you the S'mores Sticker Pack. Three gets you the Campfire Wallpaper Pack. Ten gets you the swipe file I write client ads from.
🎧 Have You Listened To The Podcast?
Same campfire, longer conversations. Listen on Apple Podcasts or listen on Spotify.
References
1. AdMakeAI, "Meta Ads Updates: November 2026 Changelog for Media Buyers," citing Birch, Meta Q3 2026 earnings and Jon Loomer, admakeai.com (Nov 2, 2026)
2. Birch, "How to run Black Friday Facebook Ads for the upcoming holidays," bir.ch (Oct 29, 2026)
3. PPC News Feed, "Merchant Center passkey requirement," ppcnewsfeed.com (Oct 25, 2026)

